Judge Halts Expansion of Florida Immigration Detention Center
A federal judge has put a stop to plans for expanding Florida’s controversial “Alligator Alcatraz” immigration detention center located in the Everglades. U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams issued a preliminary injunction, solidifying an earlier decision she made two weeks prior.
The ongoing hearings have revealed various testimonies aimed at determining if construction on the facility should cease until the matter is fully resolved. Critics, including environmental advocates and the Miccosukee Tribe, argue that expanding this center would infringe upon vital environmental regulations, threatening delicate wetlands that shelter numerous plants and animals. They assert that this project could undo billions invested in environmental conservation.
On the other side, attorneys representing state and federal authorities claim that the facility operates under Florida’s jurisdiction, exempting it from certain federal environmental laws. However, Judge Williams concluded that the detention center operates as a partnership between both state and federal governments.
The judge noted that the number of detainees at the facility is expected to decrease within two months as individuals are moved to other locations. She indicated that fencing, lighting, and generators must be removed during this period. Nevertheless, modifications deemed necessary for safety could still proceed.
The ruling has faced criticism from state officials. Florida’s Attorney General’s office denounced the decision, stating that the judge exceeded her authority. Governor Ron DeSantis also expressed his discontent, suggesting that the ruling was predetermined. He emphasized the state’s determination to uphold its mission aligned with the Trump administration’s goal of addressing illegal immigration.
President Trump had previously toured the facility and proposed that it could serve as a model for future immigration centers nationwide. While currently housing approximately 500 detainees, the facility could eventually accommodate up to 3,000 individuals. Reports have emerged detailing harsh conditions inside, where detainees face inadequate living situations, including unsanitary food, insufficient access to showers, and limited communication with family and legal counsel.
As Florida state officials prepare to appeal the recent ruling, they remain focused on their commitment to immigration enforcement while balancing environmental concerns and legal challenges.
