Dontay Jamar Garner Decatur, AL Death and Obituary – The Decatur, Alabama community is mourning the tragic loss of Dontay Jamar Garner, a 20-year-old young man who was shot and killed outside the 5th Avenue Food Mart on Thursday evening, October 30, 2025. The heartbreaking incident has left family, friends, and residents in deep shock, as they remember a life cut short by senseless violence.
According to reports from the Decatur Police Department, officers and emergency medical personnel responded to a shooting call at approximately 6:33 p.m. Upon arrival, they found Dontay Garner suffering from a gunshot wound outside the convenience store located on 5th Avenue. Despite lifesaving efforts, Garner was pronounced deceased at the scene by the Morgan County Coroner’s Office.
Authorities quickly detained 21-year-old Xavier Rashawn Sutherlin, who allegedly remained at the scene following the shooting. After an initial investigation, Sutherlin was arrested and charged with murder in connection with Garner’s death. He is currently being held without bond at the Morgan County Jail. Officials have confirmed that the investigation remains active as detectives work to determine the motive and circumstances that led to the fatal encounter.
The tragic event has sent waves of sorrow throughout the Decatur community. Those who knew Dontay describe him as a kind-hearted and humble young man with a bright future ahead. Friends have taken to social media to share memories and express their disbelief, calling his death “a devastating loss” and “a reminder of how fragile life can be.”
Neighbors in the area also expressed concerns about rising violence and the need for stronger community programs to help young people avoid such tragic outcomes. Many residents have called for unity and support for Garner’s family during this difficult time.
In the wake of the shooting, local leaders and law enforcement officials have urged the public to come together and support one another while allowing investigators to complete their work. Authorities continue to ask anyone with additional information about the incident to contact the Decatur Police Department’s Violent Crimes Unit.
Funeral arrangements for Dontay Jamar Garner have not yet been publicly announced. His family is expected to release details regarding visitation and services in the coming days.
Garner’s untimely death serves as yet another painful reminder of the devastating effects of gun violence and the lives it continues to claim. As the Decatur community grieves, loved ones are focusing on honoring his memory, remembering his laughter, compassion, and the joy he brought to those around him.
May his family and friends find strength and comfort as they mourn this heartbreaking loss.
